The Douglas Mattress vs The Hudson Mattress: Which One is Best for You?

If you are in the market for a new mattress, you may have encountered the Douglas Mattress and the Hudson Mattress while searching online or in-store. 

Both are popular choices and are made by reputable companies that specialize in creating quality mattresses and pillows. The Douglas Mattress features quality construction and excellent materials at an affordable price. 

It is a great choice if you are looking for performance, high quality, and value in one mattress. The Hudson Mattress from www.directbed.ca features quality construction and excellent materials at an affordable price. It is the perfect choice if you are looking for performance, high quality, and value in one mattress. 

However, each of these mattresses has its strengths and weaknesses that make them suitable for some people but not others – read on to learn more about the differences between these two models so you can decide which one will be best for your needs!

The Hudson Mattress

Inspired by Quebec’s beautiful town of Hudson, the Hudson is the brand's mid-level tight top foam blend mattress. Sleepers will feel at peace with this forest-like tranquility, transporting them away from tomorrow's stressful lives and worries. The Hudson also has 2 baby brothers: the London Suite and the Georgian Suite if you are looking for firmer mattress with a lower price. 

Firmness

The Hudson mattress falls at a 6.5 out of 10 on the mattress firmness scale—a softer one than what you might expect if it were marketed as medium-firm, which would fall at about a 7.5 out of 10 or higher.

Top layers offer some initial sinkage and pressure relief while also providing bounce thanks to the below foam support system that works through your body rather than just your hips and shoulders.

This light bounciness is a sweet spot for combination sleepers looking for just enough give when rolling over but do not want it so much that they always fall off their bed at night!

 

Performance

A mattress can feel different for people depending on their body weight and preferred sleeping position. Below, we will discuss each one of them:

Back Sleepers

These sleepers should find the Hudson quite comfortable. The mattress offers them an initial feeling of reduced pressure while at the same time keeping their spine aligned so they can wake up refreshed.

Side Sleepers

Light side sleepers can take advantage of this bed's soft pillow top, providing much-needed hip and shoulder pressure relief.

Stomach Sleepers

These sleepers might find the Hudson too medium for them (if you are looking for extra firm). I recommend checking out the London Suite to find an extra firm mattress, more suited to stomach sleepers. The London suite is also less expensive than the Hudson Suite. 

Pain Relief Performance

One consideration when looking for a new bed is the degree of pain relief it provides. The best indication of this is pressure relief, which checks if the bed can effectively relieve tension in certain areas like the shoulders, hips, and lower back. Ideally, you want to find a balance between both comfort and support for maximum pain relief benefits.

Back Pain

The Hudson brings some relief to my tense lower back, but the best mattress for back pain would be a little firmer and offer more body contouring in the lower back. So, I would recommend steering sleepers with back pain away from this bed and instead to the Banff Suite Mattress.

Shoulder Pain

The weightless feeling of its supportive mattress and the warmth from the surrounding blanket made this a perfect place for me to sleep. With its specially designed zones, it was easy to find just the right amount of pressure relief to keep my sleeping position comfortable and free from soreness.

Hip Pain

The pressure map indicates that this bed might not be comfortable for people who suffer from hip pain. I recommend one of our most supportive mattresses for those with hip pain instead. Our recommendation for those with hip pain would be the Banff Suite Mattress, or the Muskoka suite mattress if you are looking for a lower price. 

 

Construction and Materials

Next, let us take a closer look at the Hudson - because it makes you feel warm in the winter and cool and comfortable (in the summer!). This 10-inch modern foam mattress has this cool cooling feature and a tight-pillow top. Let us discuss in detail below:

Cover

The Hudson Mattress Cover is made from a combination of bamboo blend, for cooler sleep, and stronger, longer lasting wear. The Bamboo cover on the Hudson Mattress makes it significantly better than the Douglas Mattress in terms of longevity and quilted comfort. 

Pillow Top

The quilted mattress cover was stuffed with two inches of contouring foam to give you the feeling of sleeping on a pillow top. This layer provides good initial pressure relief.

Comforting Layer

As for the next layer of my mattress, it was made up of memory foam that has been infused with copper. It provides some back support but also ensures proper airflow throughout my bed.

Transition

Next up is a layer of foam that responds to pressure and lowers you down onto the springy coil like support below.

Support

This mattress offers true orthopedic, high density support foam giving you robust support right where you need it. It had a 3.5 lb density support foam which you could really feel. It provide an almost “thud” like feel when you sat down on it. 

Base

A thin layer of high-density base support foam surrounds the bottom of the bed. This gave a final layer of support at the bottom where the box spring will meet with the bed

Who is the Douglas Mattress ideal for?

Side sleepers will love how plush, pressure-relieving and cozy this mattress feels. Couples might prefer how they will not be bothered by a restless partner trying to find comfort on the Hudson or the Douglas Mattress. And hot sleepers will delight in how cool this mattress keeps you throughout the night.

Who should not Buy Douglas Mattress?

Stomach sleepers need a firm mattress to support their hips. So once again, stomach sleepers may not like the Douglas mattress since it is a medium feel. 

The Douglas Mattress

With Canadians designing and building it, this mattress is a great mattress for those looking for an easy-going yet practical option. It is made of only foam material, so there are no springs or coils, which makes it easier to clean but also means lower support than a coil mattress. 

At only $900 CAD (approximately USD $690), this mattress will not break the bank either! The Douglas, a foam mattress that feels just right and comes at an affordable price, is one of the most important items in their inventory. 

With our detailed review, we hope to provide you with enough information about it to decide if it will work well for your bedroom - all based on how it was made and its performance capabilities.

Firmness

Canada's mattresses are tested for firmness, just like the American ones! The firmness scale goes from 1 to 10, with 1 being the softest and 10 being the firmest. 6.5 stands for the medium-firm industry standard, not 5. 

Even though Douglas felt a little softer than average, I would still rate it an 8 out of 10 on my rating system, where 1 means soft and 10 means firm. Firmness can mean different things depending on what position you are sleeping in, so I tested this next.

One of the most important things for me when choosing a mattress is how well it supports my body and does not restrict movement. In general, people who prefer sleeping on one side or alternating between both sides would be able to find comfort with Douglas. 

This mattress's gentle yet firm nature supported me in my shoulders when I needed it most and allowed me to switch positions effortlessly without worrying about going too high off the bed or sinking too far into a soft surface. This made for a comfortable night, no matter what position I was trying.

Performance

Different people have different preferences for how they sleep, but there are some things you should know before choosing a mattress.

Back Sleepers

The Douglas mattress will offer these sleepers a feeling of weightlessness because it has just the right amount of support. A gentle sinking sensation should greet them when they lie down on this mattress while ensuring that their spine stays aligned.

Side Sleepers

These sleepers will find that Douglas is just supportive enough. A bed with even a slightly higher firmness would probably be too hard, Douglas. The memory foam should cradle the body nicely while also providing some added pressure relief.

Stomach Sleepers

Sleepers should be mindful that they may sink too deeply into the bed if they choose a lower level of firmness.

Pain Relief Performance

To figure out which areas would cause a sleeper to feel discomfort, there are noticeable differences in the amount of pain you would feel. And here is what we found:

Back Pain

What makes the Douglas Pillow so great is its ability to stay neutral without over-bending or under-bending, which helps keep the spine aligned. This does not apply as much for stomach sleepers with back pain because it only really gives support in one area. What does apply, though, are the soft and comforting aspects that work well for side sleepers who need some relief from stress on their joints, muscles, and tendons.

Shoulder Pain 

People who sleep on their stomachs may experience hip pain from this bed, but you will get some relief from shoulder soreness if you sleep on your side.

Hip Pain

People who sleep on their back with hip pain will find no discomfort in any major pressure points, while stomach sleepers might notice that the hips can sometimes come out too far. 

This can cause minor discomforts, such as spinal curvature and increased pain for side sleepers, though this is not serious enough to impact the quality of their slumber.

Construction and Materials

The Douglas consists of four layers-- all consisting solely of foam. To understand the effect of these various layers, we will break them down:

Cover

The CoolSense® cover of this Tencel blend will make you sleep cool. If you do not already know, the cover is thin and breathable, so it does not add too much weight or heat to your bedding. Not only that, but it is machine-washable!

Comfort

The first layer of ecoLight® gel memory foam cradled my body as it had always been; never before did I feel relief from the usual sensation of bouncing back from a solid surface. But best of all, the gel infusion warded off any sense of overheating by quickly responding to whatever pressure you put on it.

Transition

Elastex foam, which measures 2 in height and is slightly firmer than the previous layer of cooling gel foam, serves as a latex foam alternative while giving this mattress an extra bounce. 

This material has been specially designed to draw heat away from sleepers.

Base

The final foundational layer of the Douglas is a polyurethane spring medium-density (medium) foam. These 6 slabs provide a firm, shape-setting foundation for the mattress, supporting its weight while also serving as an anchor point for those who sleep below it.

For whom is Douglas Mattress ideal?

Side and combo sleepers alike can appreciate the pressure relief this relatively soft mattress provides and its ability to change positions easily. Other features that might appeal to a variety of sleeping styles include its cooling effect, noise-dampening qualities, and edge support—all pluses for both side and back/combo sleepers.

Who should not Buy Douglas Mattress?

Strict stomach sleepers may find it uncomfortable to sleep on the Douglas because there is not enough support for the hips.

Conclusion

After weighing all the important factors, we conclude that the best mattress for most people is the Hudson mattress. 

Its thick top layer of foam adds comfort and eliminates any feeling of sinking in; its dense bottom layer of foam provides a satisfying springy feel with adequate sinkage, and its resilient support base ensures reliable support without bottoming out. 

The Hudson mattress has bamboo quilting and is stronger and cooler than the Douglas Mattress. Hudson Mattresses are made in Canada (not China), hand sewn in Canadian Factories compared to the Douglas mattresses. 

Overall, the layout gives your body all it needs to get a healthy night's sleep while also feeling pain-free when you wake up in the morning! Hop over to Directbed to get 25% Off on Hudson Mattress (Limited Time Offer) and start sleeping better.